0711-4009550

Book appointment: Stuttgart | Karlsruhe

Book Appointment

Contact

Laser eye test
Laser eye test
Menu Trigger

Laser Eye Surgery under 45

Laser eye surgery offers a completely new lease on life. Clear vision without glasses or contact lenses thanks to laser eye surgery.

read more

Treatments

Refractive Errors

Laser eye surgery over 45

You want to read without glasses again? Laser eye surgery for presbyopia makes it possible.

read more

Treatments

Refractive errors

Costs

Laser eye surgery in Stuttgart

read more

Laser eye surgery in Karlsruhe

read more

Our Team

Not a laser eye surgery patient?

0711-4009550

Contact us

ICL or Laser: Is ICL better than FemtoLASIK or SMILE®PRO?

Avatar
Dr. med. Daniel Bányai

ICL or laser: When choosing the right vision correction methods, you often stumble across the many shortcuts. ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens) , Femto-LASIK and SMILE®PRO (Small Incision Lenticule Extraction) are three leading techniques that have given many people a new life by providing clear vision without glasses or contact lenses. Each method has its unique advantages.

ICL or laser – an overview

When choosing surgical treatment for a visual defect, the fundamental question quickly arises: ICL or laser? In order to provide more clarity here, we describe in the following chapters both the ICL method and, with femto-LASIK and SMILE®PRO, two common eye laser methods.

ICL: The Flexible Method

ICL stands for Implantable Collamer Lens. This is a procedure in which a biocompatible lens is inserted into the eye. It’s like having permanent contact lenses that you never feel, see, or need to replace.

ICLs are ideal for people with high vision, thin corneas or dry eyes.

Implantable lenses provide their wearers with sharp, reliable vision. ICLs are reversible – they can be completely removed after treatment.

Femto-LASIK: Precision at its best

Femto-LASIK uses a laser to create a thin incision in the cornea. Then another laser reshapes the underlying cornea.

The procedure is quick, and most people return to their normal activities within a day. Precision and speed make Femto-LASIK a popular choice, especially for those with moderate vision defects who prefer a short recovery time.

SMILE®PRO: Minimally invasive, maximally effective

SMILE®PRO is the latest method of vision correction. It is a minimally invasive procedure that uses a laser to create and remove a small piece of corneal tissue to reshape the eye.

Due to the ultra-precise work of the laser, the recovery for the patient is fast and the risks are reduced. It is a fantastic option for people with mild to moderate myopia.

Laser or ICL: Which method is best?

So, is ICL better than eye lasers with femto-LASIK or SMILE® Pro? There is no answer to this question.

Every eye is unique – so there is no “best” method that suits everyone. High vision defects and certain prerequisites could make ICL treatment the best choice for some people. Others achieve the best balance between precision and recovery time with Femto-LASIK or SMILE®PRO.

The winning method is the one that suits you best. We take into account your lifestyle, eye health and vision goals. A consultation will help you make an informed decision.

Schedule a consultation now

Take the next step

Would you like to find out whether ICL, Femto-LASIK or SMILE®PRO suits you best?

Start with our aptitude test. You will receive an initial assessment of the extent to which a laser treatment is suitable for you. Answer a few simple questions (approx. 2 minutes) about your vision and the previous vision aids.

Avatar

Written by Dr. med. Daniel Bányai

Dr. med. Daniel Bányai is an ophthalmologist at Bányai Neue Augen and specialises in refractive laser eye treatments at the Stuttgart and Karlsruhe locations.

More about Dr. med. Daniel Bányai

All the information on laser eye surgery – straight to your inbox!

By signing up, you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Share post

Follow us

More about Laser Eye Surgery

Laser Eye Surgery
Kosten für das Augenlasern in der Türkei vs. Kosten in Deutschland

Laser eye surgery costs in Turkey vs. costs in Germany

Laser eye treatments in Turkey offer a cost-effective alternative to treatments in other countries. While prices can be significantly cheaper, it is important to consider the quality and reputation of the clinic. Read more about the costs and what to consider when choosing a clinic.

Laser eye methods 2026: The latest procedures in laser eye surgery

Eye lasers can be used to improve defective vision. There are different methods to achieve good results. Read here which eye laser methods are available and for whom they are suitable.

Eye lasers & dioptres: up to what value is it possible according to Dr. med. Bányai?

In the meantime, an enormous spectrum of refractive errors and diopter values can be treated with lasers. In the following article, we will explain to you up to which values treatment is possible and which methods are suitable.

Driving after laser eye surgery – when can you get behind the wheel? Doctor-medic Bányai explains

Opting for laser eye treatment is a bold decision that can pay off with a life free of glasses and contact lenses. It is often helpful to know how quickly you can return to your normal daily routine after the operation. A frequently asked question is: “When can you drive after laser eye surgery?”

Does the health insurance company pay for laser eye surgery? Tips from Doctor-medic Bányai

Defective vision such as cataracts and age-related macular degeneration are one of the most common eye diseases. When the health insurance company pays and what options there are, if not, you can find out here!

How should I behave after laser eye surgery?

In the hours after laser eye surgery, you should rest. Protect your eyes and avoid reading or watching TV. Your eyes should have recovered from the procedure by the next day. This article explains how much rest you need after laser eye surgery and what to watch out for afterward.